The case for staying, the case for going, and how to tell which is yours

On the Monday following your performance review, it is not the rating that keeps circling back to you. It is the one from the Deloitte survey a colleague passed along with no comment: just 5% of women expect to remain with their current employer for more than five years. You have been at your Clayton office for nine. You scan the line a second time and then close the laptop with a click.

Nothing was wrong with the review process. "Solid year. Carry on as you are." Your manager delivered it warmly and sincerely, and that is the trouble. Staying put, as things stand, is a standstill. Nobody on the leadership team got told to keep doing what they had been doing. They were asked where they wanted to go next, across the St. Louis region.

What's riding on this for women here in St. Louis

Stay, and you keep what is hard to rebuild: the trust you have earned, the colleagues who finish your thoughts in meetings, the retirement match that fully vests in two years, a drive down I-64 you could make with your eyes closed. Plateaus, for their part, last only as long as you let them, and you can hold one in place just as you can hold any other position.

Go, and you exchange all of that for a story that has not been written yet. Picture a fresh supervisor who knows nothing of how things work here, plus a year spent proving again what you already demonstrated ten years earlier. In St. Louis, as elsewhere, the recruiter means her enthusiasm, yet her payment arrives when you accept an offer, not when you feel satisfied where you are.

The turning point

That 5% says nothing against remaining where you are. What it does flag is remaining out of pure routine. None of the women surveyed in that report are saying they plan to walk out the door. What they refuse to do is guarantee they will stay put, and that stance is both distinct and more prudent. Consequently, the question worth asking is not if you deserve a spot in the 5%. Ask instead whether, if this same job, pay, and manager were presented to you as a brand-new opportunity today, you would say yes. If yes, stay with clear eyes. When your reasoning amounts to "at least it's familiar," then you have your answer, and familiarity is not a reason to stay.

Why this reaches beyond one review in St. Louis

Across 15 countries, the Deloitte study surveyed 7,500 women and reported that 36% felt their stress had climbed over the last twelve months, while 29% rated their mental health as poor. Those numbers measure something other than commitment. It is exhaustion. Nine years in a position that stopped developing you around year five does not reflect loyalty. Instead, you are slowly being absorbed, and any appreciation the organization offers will arrive as a note rather than a raise.

Three actions to tackle before the week is out

To begin. Draft the two offers. On one page, pitch your current job the way a recruiter would: title, pay, manager, scope, next step. Draft, on a separate sheet, the most compelling alternative you can realistically pursue. Read both cold. At least one of those options should be a role you would genuinely accept.

Next. Raise the point your review failed to address. Ask, "What would I need to demonstrate to be considered for the next level, and what is the timeline?" A concrete reply includes a deadline. "Carry on as you are" does not.

Finally. Over coffee in St. Louis, have one exchange with someone who works outside your company. Not an interview, just coffee. In roughly an hour you will learn your market value from people who have not already decided what you are worth. In the St. Louis region, groups such as Women Empowering Women, Little Black Book chapters in O'Fallon or St. Charles, or CREW-St. Louis make that first meeting easy to arrange.

That figure was never a signal that you should walk away. It was showing you that most women have stopped assuming they will stay, and that it may be time you stopped assuming it too.

Sources: