How to price what you'd give up, what you'd get back, and the number that sets you free

Refer to her as Lorraine. She is a composite built for this article, not an actual member or client. At 54 she serves as chief financial officer of a division, and recently she did the very thing finance professionals are trained for yet tend to dodge, namely putting a hard figure on a dilemma. She has priced her own handcuffs.

Written across the top of her legal pad is a total of $410,000. That sum rolls together her unvested stock, a retention payment due in nineteen months, and deferred pay she would lose by walking away. These numbers are hypothetical, yet they feel very real to her. Underneath them she has written the other number, the one she has never said out loud: four years of not being considered for the group CFO role, with a new candidate brought in from outside each time.

What she would forfeit

Staying means she takes home the $410,000, holds onto her title, keeps the team she assembled, and continues her Tuesday lunches with the general counsel. She also keeps the pattern. In practice, a division CFO post is the seat this company fills with people it values but has no intention of elevating further. Two men have cycled through that same chair on their way to bigger roles. Neither stayed four years.

Should she leave, she leaves the money behind. Nineteen months' worth of payments disappear, and so does the equity. A headhunter phoned about a CFO opening at a publicly traded firm and stated plainly that the base pay would be on par with what she earns now. The recruiter said far less about the rest of the package.

The turning point

Lorraine redoes the arithmetic, just as she would for a client sitting across from her in a conference room in Clayton. The $410,000 is not $410,000. Spread over the nineteen months she would need to stay, it amounts to close to $21,500 each month before taxes. That is what each month of waiting genuinely costs her. Next she poses a question she has never before put to herself: what is one month of her career worth when she is 54? Not to the company. To her. And the next question, the one that changes everything: who else might be willing to pay it?

After all, employers pay to dissolve golden handcuffs routinely. Sign-on payments and make-whole equity grants were created with exactly this kind of situation in mind. Her $410,000 is a number to negotiate, not a wall she cannot climb. It is an opening offer.

Why this extends well beyond Lorraine

Per McKinsey and LeanIn's Women in the Workplace 2025 findings, only 54% of companies place women's advancement among their top priorities. Most of the rest still allocate money to retention. Frequently a retention bonus stands in for an actual career plan, and its size does not turn it into one.

Here in St. Louis, the stakes are concrete. Many finance leaders in the region work for large employers such as Centene, Emerson, Edward Jones and Graybar, where executive pay and equity can run deep, which makes the cost of leaving easy to underestimate. Before you weigh a move, it helps to know the local market. Metro median earnings for women were about 72 cents on each dollar of men's median earnings in 2024, so a make-whole offer is worth pricing carefully rather than accepting by default. Local groups such as ACG St. Louis Women's Peer Group, CREW-St. Louis and the St. Louis Women Leaders Association can help you test these numbers with peers before you talk to a recruiter.

Three takeaways stand out from it

Step one. Price the cuffs honestly. Tally every benefit you would lose by leaving, then divide that total by the months you would have to stay to receive it. The resulting monthly amount is what each month of waiting truly costs you, and it proves far smaller than the headline lump sum suggests.

Step two. Have the market cover that cost. Say something like, "My unvested compensation comes to roughly X. What would it take to make me whole?" Raise it with the recruiter during the first call, not at the end. Mature companies budget for precisely this. The ones that are not serious will reveal it by steering the conversation elsewhere.

Step three. Settle on your walk-away number before the pressure arrives. Name the figure that would persuade you to move, along with the deadline after which no figure would. Once you have that, you are bargaining from a concrete number instead of a gut feeling.

Lorraine's legal pad now carries three figures. The first is what it costs her to stay. The next figure is what a rival firm could realistically offer. The final figure is the sum she has firmly decided she will take.

Sources: