It takes 15 seconds, and it tells you exactly where you stand

Many one-on-ones amount to a status report on a calendar invitation. You go through your list, your manager nods along, and you walk out knowing what you knew before you walked in, which is little about your standing. Few people appreciate how heavily that blind spot weighs on their careers. According to McKinsey and LeanIn's 2025 Women in the Workplace report, roughly 93 women get promoted to manager for every 100 men, and among women of color that figure drops to 74. That same study revealed that 80% of women seek advancement, versus 86% of men, and that this gap disappears once women get the same backing. Support depends on information, and that information usually begins with a single question: "When my name comes up, what do people say?"

The tally

Think back over your final four one-on-ones and tell yourself yes or no to each item that follows. Your answers stay private, and keeping them that way is exactly what makes this useful.

Step 1. Are you aware of the targets your manager has to hit by the end of this quarter?

Step 2. Over the last month, have you raised questions about where you stand, rather than limiting yourself to discussing your tasks?

Step 3. Are you aware of which of your projects your manager mentions when speaking with senior leadership?

Step 4. Has your manager ever openly walked through what your next position could look like?

Step 5. Could you name the single adjustment your manager hopes you will make to your working style?

Step 6. Do you take part in shaping at least some of what gets covered in those meetings?

Step 7. When you last shared an accomplishment, did you spell out why it mattered in addition to what you did?

Step 8. Are the dates of the next talent review or calibration session on your radar?

Step 9. Over the past three months, have you asked directly what people say about you when your name comes up?

Step 10. Coming out of your latest one-on-one, did you learn anything new that you had no grasp of before it began?

Reading your score

Eight to ten: well-informed. Do your one-on-ones deliver the value they were designed to deliver? Do you treat them as a chance to collect information rather than simply deliver it, and does your manager understand your goals and their timing?

Four to seven: staying in the loop. Most people land on this result, and it is a result you can move. Your work is strong and you present it clearly, yet your manager is receiving status reports when she could be receiving a argument for your next step.

Zero to three: working in the dark. This is not a character flaw. Nobody explained that a one-on-one is really a contest for attention, and managers rarely volunteer that point on their own.

Your following step

If you scored eight to ten, ask the question anyway this week and pay attention to what has changed since your last conversation. Position shifts, and frequently it happens without much notice.

If you scored four to seven, trim your status update by half before your next one-on-one and spend the saved minutes asking one forward-looking question. You can send the status update over email, and your manager will probably welcome having it in writing.

With a score of zero to three, lead your next one-on-one by asking that question first. Fifteen seconds. Then stop talking. Every reply your manager gives after that, even the pause that comes before she speaks, reveals where you stand. A prompt, concrete answer signals that your name is in circulation, and now you know what is being said about you. A lengthy hesitation signals that you are not there yet, and you learn this a full year sooner than a performance review would have revealed it.

Tally your yeses, then send this along to the woman whose one-on-ones you admire most.