The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe

Executive presence tends to be the sort of judgment people form about you silently, rarely putting it into words. Someone tells you that you need more of it, no one can explain what it looks like, and before long you are second-guessing your wardrobe. Pause there. Those judging it are weighing three things: whether you can be relied on to make a call, whether people listen when you talk, and whether you keep your composure when things go sideways. Your clothes do not enter into it. The fuzziness is not accidental. Across St. Louis and its surrounding communities, researchers have documented how an identical request is heard as confident when a man makes it but as pushy when a woman does, and "presence" offers an easy hiding place for that double standard.

The quick test

Answer yes or no, drawing on the past month of your work in Eastern Missouri. Count what actually took place, not what you would have done in theory.

Start. Lead with the bottom line when you propose something, then walk through why it makes sense.

Next. In a meeting, you openly pushed back against a more senior colleague.

Then. Your team's mission can be captured in a single sentence that someone unfamiliar with your work could repeat back accurately.

After that. When a problem surfaces, colleagues bring it to you first, before escalating it to someone above you.

Fifth step. In a St. Louis meeting, you let the quiet sit instead of hurrying to cover it.

Sixth step. You admitted you lacked an answer, promised a timeline of Thursday, and delivered on that promise.

Seven. Your messages to St. Louis senior leaders tend to be trimmer than the replies you receive from them.

Last but one. When a senior leader asked for something you could not provide, you declined and explained why in one concise sentence.

Ninth in line. You looked composed in a room where the tension was palpable.

Final item. In a later meeting, a colleague echoed a line of yours back to the group.

How to interpret your score

Eight to ten: well established. People in the room already regard you as someone who decides. If you are still receiving the feedback, ask who is offering it and what they really mean, because it may not be about you at all.

Four to seven: developing. Your instincts are reliable, and you already display a number of the markers. What remains is mainly a matter of pace and brevity: stating the recommendation at the outset, keeping emails tight, and holding your silence while the room catches up.

Zero to three: capable yet restrained. You do the work and let others decide what it adds up to. That is not a personal flaw. Many of us were taught to show our reasoning before earning the conclusion, and that was good advice for the classroom, not for a boardroom.

Your next step

A score from eight to ten calls for a specific step: the next time someone mentions "presence," respond with, "What specifically would you like to see differently in the next meeting?" and record what they say. When no concrete answer is forthcoming, the gap itself reveals something about the quality of the feedback.

A score from four to seven calls for a one-month experiment: begin every update by stating the decision you are seeking in the opening sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.

A score from zero to three calls for a small step at your next meeting: voice one brief disagreement with the most senior person present, then stop speaking. One sentence is enough. Consider opening with, "Here is where I part ways, and my reasoning," then pause so they can weigh in. The silence that follows your remark is itself a form of presence.

Tally your yeses, then share this with the woman in your St. Louis office who was told she needs more presence but never learned what that actually meant.