Four things to negotiate before you sign, including the one HR hopes you won't notice

A severance package is an opening bid, not a final ruling. The company wants you to sign a release of claims, and the amount it has put on the table is, by its own estimate, the smallest sum you will accept. According to a 2026 AARP survey, roughly two in three workers past 50 say they have faced age bias in their jobs. That helps explain why the release is the document HR most wants signed quickly and least wants questioned.

You are entitled to question it. If you are over 40, federal law guarantees you a window to review the paperwork before you commit. Take the full window, and work through the checklist below before replying to anyone in the company.

The checklist to review

Read the offer that arrived in your inbox and answer yes or no to each statement.

Step A. The severance payment exceeds the company's standard formula, or you have asked what that formula is.

Step B. Instead of simply letting you buy your own coverage, the company covers your health insurance premiums for a specified number of months.

Step C. The letter spells out whether your current-year bonus will be paid entirely or pro rata, so check which one applies.

Step D. Equity or retention pay that would have vested in the next few months is accelerated or paid out.

Step E. The departure date in the letter is set around your needs, not just around the company's staffing numbers.

Step F. The separation reason is worded so it will not damage your next job search, such as "position eliminated."

Step G. Both the company and you are bound by the non-disparagement provision.

Step H. Any non-compete or non-solicitation limit is drawn tightly enough to leave open the job you are most likely to pursue next.

Step I. The package includes outplacement help, a letter of recommendation, or a pre-agreed script for reference checks.

Step ten Before you sign, you have either had an attorney look over the release of claims or intend to do so.

Reading your score

0 to 3: Your offer follows the usual boilerplate. Nobody built this offer around your situation, and that includes the dollar figure. That is not a judgment of you. The offer is a first move in a negotiation, and first moves are expected to be countered.

4 to 7: Some terms were likely negotiated already, perhaps for the last person who left. Because the shortfalls are concrete, you can point to each one directly and ask for it to be fixed.

8 to 10: Your package is a solid one, especially by Eastern Missouri standards. Your job from here is to safeguard that package by checking that each promised term actually shows up in the final signed document, and by spending your review window reading the release line by line instead of relaxing.

Actions to take

With a 0 to 3 score, a single email covering four asks is the best move: additional weeks of severance, employer-paid health coverage for a fixed period, a pro-rated bonus, and a non-disparagement obligation that runs both ways. A sample opening could read: "Thank you for sending this over. Before I sign, I would like to discuss four items." The company has room in its budget for this conversation, and it expected one.

With a 4 to 7 score, pick the two items you marked as missing that matter most to you and name them directly in your reply. Asking for something precise tends to get a quicker reply than voicing a broad objection.

With an 8 to 10 score, get an attorney to review the release along with any restrictive covenants before you commit. The item HR hopes you won't spot is usually the non-compete, since a broad one costs the company nothing but can cost you your next offer.

If you want to compare notes, share your score anonymously with other women who may face this next. A good number of them treat the initial figure as though it could not be negotiated.